Candy Store Header Image

Hand-Made Candies

You will feel like a kid again when you enter The Chocolate Affair! Create your own customized box of hand made chocolates from a selection including turtles, butter creams, clusters & barks! Truffles and sugar free are included in the offerings and make decision making difficult! We also offer a wide selection of seasonal and holiday candies and custom chocolate favors for every occasion!
Hand Made Chocolates
All chocolates are $16/pound plus tax/shipping
Available box sizes are:

  • 1/4 Pound
  • 1/2 Pound
  • 3/4 Pound (Clear Top box)
  • 1 Pound (Double layer or Oval Window box available)
  • 1 1/2 Pound (Clear top box)
  • 2 Pound box (Clear top box)

Caramel Patties (Turtles):
The Classic, Everyone's Favorite!

Hand Made Chocolates Available in: Milk, Dark or White Chocolate
Nut Options: Pecan, Cashew or Almond
Added twist: Add Cranberries or Blueberries!
Sea Turtles: Peanuts, Caramel, & Sea Salt

Hand-Dipped Caramels

Hand Dipped Caramels Available in: Milk, Dark and White Chocolate
Extra Special: Sea salt caramels, Coffee Caramels, Peanut butter Blankets (Caramels topped with peanut butter!)

Chocolate Affair Specialties

Chocolate Affair Specialties Our customers have told us time and again these are their favorite treats
Options: Caramel pretzel rod, S'more w/ Homemade marshmallow, Mint Oreo Bark, Butter Almond Toffee, Chocolate dipped Potato Chips, Chocolate Twinkies, Caramallow Pops


truffles The ultimate in decadence
Options: Flavors subject to availablity.
  • 4 peice (clear box): $3.75
  • 1/4#, 8 pieces: $6.75
  • 1/2#, 20 pieces: $16.00
  • 3/4#, 25 pieces: $21.50
  • 1#, 36 pieces: $28.00

Gourmet Chocolate Bars

Chocolate Bars Our customers have told us time and again these are their favorite treats
Options: Bacon Maple, Toasted Almond Sea Salt, Toasted Coconut Almond, Peanut Butter Crunch, Potato Chip, Coffee

Real Butter Creams

Real Butter Creams Available in: Milk, Dark or White Chocolate
Options: Chocolate, butter, vanilla, peanut butter, lime, lemon, orange, strawberry, raspberry, cherry, coconut, cappuccino, butter pecan, ginger spice, kahlua, pineapple, peppermint, eggnog, champagne, root beer, and maple.


Clusters Available in: Milk, Dark or White Chocolate
Options: Pretzel, raisin, almond, cranberry, cranberry raisin, peanut, cashew, coconut(Haystacks), blueberry, and triple cherry.

Gift Certificates

A gift certificate to The Chocolate Affair is the perfect gift for any chocolate lover! Let them come to the shop to taste and choose the perfect chocolates or give them a nights stay at the Tibbetts House! Available in any denomination.

Delightful combinations enrobed in chocolate!

Barks Available in: Milk, Dark or White Chocolate
Options: Peacon, almond, crispy cranberry cashew, pistachio cherry, cherry almond, raspberry, orange, strawberry, krispie caramel, caramel pretzel, margarita, pina colada, mint oreo, and crispy milk chocolate.

Chocolate Towers

Chocolate Towers
A Beautiful presentation for boxed chocolates. Other combinations available, prices may vary. Wrapping available for any occasion/holiday.
  • $10.00 1/4 # Asst. Chocolates, 1/2 # Chocolate nuts
  • $12.00 1/4 # and 1/2 # Asst. Chocolates
  • $14.50 1/4 # Asst. Truffles, 1/2 # Asst. Chocolates
  • $18.00 3/4 # Asst. Chocolates, 1/2 # Chocolate nuts
  • $18.50 3/4 # Asst. Chocolates, 1/4 # Asst. Truffles
  • $22.00 1 # Asst. Chocolates, 1/2 # Chocolate nuts
  • $22.50 1 # Asst. Chocolates, 1/4 # Asst. Truffles
  • $24.50 3/4 # Asst. Chocolates, 1/2 # Chocolate nuts, 1/4 # Asst. Truffles
  • $28.50 1 # Asst. Chocolates, 1/2 # Chocolate nuts, 1/4 # Asst. Truffles
  • $30.00 1 1/2 # Asst. Chocolates, 1/2 # Chocolate nuts
  • $36.50 1 1/2 # Asst. Chocolates, 1/2 # Chocolate nuts, 1/4 # Truffles

Candy Trays

Candy Trays Assorted Chocolates arranged on a ready to display tray.
Any price range available.
Perfect for parties and corporate gifts.

Chocolate Covered
Wine Bottle

Chocolate Covered Wine Bottle Know a wine lover? A chocolate covered wine bottle is their perfect gift! Will will triple dip the bottle of your choice with a dark chocolate, drizzled with white and packaged in a clear bag with a beautiful bow. They simply open their wine, pull the ribbon from under the chocoate and enjoy! Perfect for any occasion!

$20, plus cost of wine

Chocolate Dipped Strawberries

Chocolate Dipped Strawberries Chocolate dipped strawberries are perfect for a special gift or a decadent treat for yourself! They are made to order to ensure freshness and require 24 hour notice. A 1 pound box is $21 (approximately 8 to 12 berries) and 2 pound box is $33 (approx. 15 to 24 berries). Call to today to place your order!

Triple Chocolate Mess Cake Mix!

Triple Chocolate Mess Cake Mix! Make our trademark Triple Chocolate Mess Cake at home when you order our mix! Impress everyone at your next party or give it as a gift, the Triple Chocolate Mess Cake is always a crowd pleaser. The mix is individually packaged, complete with directions and easy to make in a crock pot. Order your mix today!

$7, plus shipping/handling

Tuxedo & Bridal Strawberries

Tuxedo & Bridal Strawberries A beautiful sweet treat representing the bride and groom on their special day. Perfect for parties, showers and the "big" day!

$3.50 each


Hand-Made Chocolate Candy Hand-Made

Build your own box of chocolates from more than 30 handmade selections, specialty candies and truffles.
View Details

Hand-Made Gifts Hand-Made

See what's in store from local crafters and artisans!

View Details


Chocolate Fountain Chocolate

The Chocolate Fountain is an innovative new way to serve chocolate and is a true "must have" at any event. The Chocolate Fountain can be surrounded with an abundance of fresh fruits and confections for your guests to dip and enjoy.
View Details

Chocolate Parties Chocolate

Gather your friends for a Chocolate Affair favorite. If you like chocolate...this is the party for you!

View Details

Handmade Chocolate Candy

The Chocolate Affair
1011 Broadway
Highland, IL 62249